Home › Top-rated pawn shops › Ohio

Top-rated pawn shops in Ohio

How this list works: shops are ranked by their Google rating weighted by their number of Google reviews, so a high rating from many reviews places above a perfect rating from a few. A shop needs at least 10 reviews, and no chain gets more than two places.

168 of the 172 pawn shops we list in Ohio have 10 or more Google reviews. 66 chain locations were left out by the two-per-chain rule. These are the top 10.

  1. #1

    All-Star Pawn

    1325 E 3rd St, Dayton, OH

    Buys gold ToolsElectronics Jewelry repair
    1,033 reviews Independent

    “GREAT PLACE! Staff greeted me with a smile and welcoming atmosphere. EXCELLENT PRICE$ & selection of tools,electronics and huge choice of Truly Beautiful Jewelry! Loans…” Google review

  2. #2

    “I went to this place because of all the great reviews they received. However if there was a option for more stars 🌟 I would definitely give them more. This place was…” Google review

  3. #3

    “I have to say I'm thoroughly impressed with Pack Rats and their staff. I'm a working musician and I've dealt with countless pawn shops over the years. I brought in a few…” Google review

  4. #4

    Luxury Jewelry & Loan

    517 E Livingston Ave #5545, Columbus, OH

    Buys gold Watches Layaway
    232 reviews Independent

    “I had such an amazing experience at this location, and have even stopped in recently after the remodel it looks stunning, best shop in the state, hands down!!!! Very…” Google review

  5. #5

    “Great guys, cool little place. Good inventory as well! Had a good conversation here in the store, was more than willing to help me out. Overall would definitely come…” Google review

  6. #6

    “This is a great, honest shop. I found them through an online platform, and so my business with them was over the phone. I was helped out by Collin primarily, and he was…” Google review

  7. #7

    CashAmerica Pawn

    533 S Reynolds Rd, Toledo, OH

    Buys gold Electronics Layaway
    130 reviews Independent

    “Everytime I go to store, Lee has such positive and courteous attitude.. Listen, can't wait to put in something in Layaway. Y'all got to come and see😭😅 give him…” Google review

  8. #8

    “I had the most amazing experience with Mike Kelch. He greeted me right away upon arrival. I stopped in visiting from out of town and I’m so happy I did. I wanted to see…” Google review

  9. #9

    “Fantastic business, people are very friendly and always helpful. Deals can be made. Great selection of tools. I have dealt with them for a few years, and they have…” Google review

  10. #10

    “This was my first time visiting a pawn shop. I don't usually sell my items, but after doing some research, this place stood out as the best option. When I went in, the…” Google review

See every pawn shop in Dayton · Findlay · Defiance · Columbus · Massillon · Delta

All pawn shops in Ohio Sell gold in Ohio Open Sundays Other states