Home › Top-rated pawn shops › Wisconsin

Top-rated pawn shops in Wisconsin

How this list works: shops are ranked by their Google rating weighted by their number of Google reviews, so a high rating from many reviews places above a perfect rating from a few. A shop needs at least 10 reviews, and no chain gets more than two places.

29 of the 29 pawn shops we list in Wisconsin have 10 or more Google reviews. 4 chain locations were left out by the two-per-chain rule. These are the top 10.

  1. #1

    “I recently came to Pawn America West Allis to find a ring that looked like my late mother’s wedding/engagement ring. I was helped by Danny and he could not have been…” Google review

  2. #2

    Pawn America

    6574 N 76th St, Milwaukee, WI

    Electronics
    2,015 reviews Chain store

    “I had a great experience at Pawn America thanks to Shameika. She was very professional, patient, and helpful throughout the whole process. She made everything easy to…” Google review

  3. #3

    Stein's Jewelry & Loan

    715 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee, WI

    Buys gold Watches Jewelry repair
    100 reviews Independent

    “My daughter and I have gone to Stein's the past couple of years to buy ourselves jewelry for our birthdays, which are close together. Just went yesterday and Renee was…” Google review

  4. #4

    “Got it—you want it maxed out and crystal clear about how different this place is: *** :::writing block Mr. Money in Appleton, Wisconsin isn’t just a pawn shop—it…” Google review

  5. #5

    “My family and I have trusted Mixa for years with expensive diamonds and hand made shell necklaces. Every time we get our jewelry back it has exceeded our expectations…” Google review

  6. #6

    “This Fast N Easy is the best pawn shop in the area. I have been coming here for many years and have purchased hundreds of different items without an issue. Bailey &…” Google review

  7. #7

    “5+ STARS! Awesome service!! I had a special watch that had the back glued on so I could not remove the battery. I took it down to J&G & the watch expert took his time &…” Google review

  8. #8

    “Great customer service and lots of cool/ handy tools and products!! From PC's to gardening tools pretty cute little shop! Even brought home a cute little skin care…” Google review

  9. #9

    “I've been a regular here for quite some time. And I have to say that this is my favorite pawn shop. The new owners, (congrats btw) are amazing people, and their staff is…” Google review

  10. #10

    Reflections Jewelry

    1306 W Forest Home Ave, Milwaukee, WI

    Buys gold ElectronicsWatches
    132 reviews Independent

    “I have been visiting Reflections for years now and they are great people. It's the one place I know I can come and always find a great priced gift for my wife. I am so…” Google review

See every pawn shop in West Allis · Milwaukee · Appleton · Menasha · Beloit · Green Bay

All pawn shops in Wisconsin Sell gold in Wisconsin Open Sundays Other states